For sale: Magic The Gathering cards

What is the best place in Cincinnati to sell old Magic cards?

I played MtG waaaaay back in the day (around 2000-2001), and have a very old repository of cards I would like to sell. In addition, many friends have given me their old cards over the years, so my stash is sizable. I have cards ranging from Revised to Ice-Age ish eras. I doubt I have any of the super-ultra-rare things, but I know I have a full set of Dual Lands I would like to get rid of (I think I have 4 of each kind, but can't remember).

I haven't played the game in over a decade, so I have no idea what things are worth. I go by what I can find online.

That said, I'm looking for a place that buys Magic singles that would be interested in some old cards.

Thanks.

A full set of 40 original duallands in decent condition will net you serious cash for openers. Go to Starcitygames.com for buy price ideas and you will get a general idea what to let them go for.

Bring your collection to Eastside games and cards to have him check it out. There are several Magic stores in the area that may be interested. If I had seen this before gencon that would have been the best place to sell them.

Thanks for the advice. I did sell a few cards this past weekend, some dual lands, some other stuff. None of the cards are in mint condition (being over 15 years old and having been used at a time before card sleeves were a thing), and I didn't have a complete set of duals like I thought I did (missing 1 Tundra and I don't think I have any of whatever the blue/red ones are).

That said, I'll continue to shop around. I generally have to call ahead to let them know I'm coming.

Still not sure what I'm going to do with the bulk though. I have a ton of very old common/uncommons. Who would be interested in buying the bulk lot? Anyone around here?